| Postgame Part 2- Bicycle Race; BICYCLE BICYCLE BICYCLE | |
|---|---|
| Tweet Topic Started: Nov 9 2013, 10:05 PM (63 Views) | |
| Teal Hunter | Nov 9 2013, 10:05 PM Post #1 |
![]()
Muse
|
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GugsCdLHm-Q the first person to notice this should Skype me or SF pm me or something because I didn't announce this at all and I want to see how long it takes for anyone to noitce One year later, player analysis postgame! Woah! I meant to post this on Halloween then I forgot whoops. i procrastinated hard on like 2 hours of work at most, but I did it eventually, so deal with it. I'm beating SDS [12:49am] <BBM> you didnt do a player analysis postgame for cmv [12:50am] <Reinfleche> i didn't? [12:50am] <BBM> i just remember a role breakdown and explanation [12:50am] <Reinfleche> oh. (this was like 2 months ago) There's a lot of places you can go wrong with player reviews because a lot of mafia is subjective and a host has a much different view of any given situation than a player does. What might seem obvious to a host could seem completely ridiculous to a player or what a player might be thinking on a situation could be dead wrong because they have no information. That said this is what I have to say! This is in order of death, which allows me to start off being really lazy with these, not that I was particularly punctual in the first place! Chao: Got lynched D1 and had 1 post. Um, yeah. Core: Basically didn't do anything and got vigged N1. Also he requested a sub sometime around the start of D2. Apparently he hadn't even bothered to check in and see if he was alive. Thanks, Core. BBM 1 the slow and calm: Was super protown D1 and wished he could selfprotect as a result of that and died N1. BBM seems to enjoy being killed N1 as doc often. See later for more comments (yeah right it's 2 sentences) Marth: Didn't do too much and died N1. Shinori: Looked really scummy and lynched D2. All these brief ones are nice. Prims: Was supertownie for while he was around, etc. Also the only person who actually tried to make use of Savior of the Dreaming Dead other than the man himself, thanks for trying to use my cool setup centralized roles. Meesh: I think you were okay when you were around. A lot of people thought you were scummy? I dunno. Weapons: weapons Pretty good while you were around. I don't think I ever had a chance at getting a sub for you but you died right after requesting one so I guess that's good? Elieson: Several people have been over why your claim was an obvious fake a bunch of times. also you reusing it in fakeclaim seriously pissed me off but that isn't this game so whatever Snike: Had to sub out near-immediately. 8[ Wasn't bad while he was around though. Ballerzak: Wasn't able to make significant use of his role. I do appreciate that he tried to utilize what little information he had, but it was too late by that point unfortunately. Wombat: happy feet wombo combo where you at I think you were good when you were around but that was not much. Your play suffered a bit later on but you started off alright. arora: People thought you were scummy earlygame but I think a lot of that was just playstyle difference? You did alright other than that. Manix: Backpacked the mafia for a while etc. His play was good on its own too. and rpd a bunch Paperblade: paperbrad ruled Tables: Had to sub pretty quick. Pretty funny to watch though Mancer: Other people already covered this in the graveyard and I don't feel like saying more of this. You don't play anymore anyway though so I guess this doesn't matter? Keltik: Inactive, sadly. kirbyviper: You did pretty good overall. Your play randomly dropped towards the middle and you ended up being inactive later but I thought you had a pretty strong earlygame and was surprised you lived as long as you did. Iris: ![]() jalmont: Modkill aside, I think jamont's play was great. He managed to keep a fairly level head and his activity was better than so much of the game with only one phase. I get that some people thought he had a bad attitude but that seemed more frustrated than malicious. scorri: One of the better town players for sure. I think you made good use of what you had and also thanks for rping Levity: One of the best anti-town players for sure. Active and came pretty close to the win! Sorry about the jalmont thing. One think I'm pretty sure that was already pointed out was that you stumbled over your claim a bit but it didn't matter that much. Also thanks for RPing Nights/ Mr guy: inactive :[ Whispy: whispy rules Aere: Oh boy. I'm not going to say much about Aere because I and everyone else gave him a hard enough time during the game. I think the worst thing you did was when you shot Balcerzak and then said you did it because other people wanted you to (even though I'm pretty sure 0 people suggested this)- as vigilante, if you don't think someone is scummy, don't shoot them! Also you really shouldn't have used all your vig shots early on- when you only have 3 it can be better to narrow the field a bit. Naglfar: didn't even read his role PM/10 BBM 2 the fast and furious: super townie super active super terrible at night actions. also, I am not sure if I mentioned this in public, but I completely forgot that BBM had already been playing until he pointed it out to me on Day 4 or so. Then I proceeded to pretend it was entirely on purpose because he died N1 and stuff. To be fair I would have let him sub back in anyway because I really, really needed subs. eclipse: I think you did a pretty good job for not knowing your role for so long. Kaoz: Never ended up using the roleblock, though there was one case where he sent in an action and cancelled it. Understandable I think, could randomly hit a useful PR and roleblocking isn't fantastic for town early anyway. Also I don't think I ever asked why you guys did this? awards Town MVP: Paperblade, most likely. jalmont might've gotten this if he wasn't modkilled, I think his play was actually very good when he was around. There were a few other contenders but I think these are the main two. Anti-Town MVP: Manix kinda backpacked his whole team for a while. Levity also played generally pretty well. I would put them at about the same here. Roleplaying MVP: Whispy, I think, for being hilarious all game. I would also like to thank everyone who bothered doing this at all. I know I wasn't very descriptive here but some of you went along with what you had, so thanks. Worst Night Actions: Either Aere for them misvigs or half the mafia team for not having any which would have really helped them Worst Luck: BBM with dying N1 and his amazingly useful night actions. scorri is a close second for being modkilled for something she didn't do. So yeah most of these aren't helpful at all and are generic. I don't care. There's some bonus material I had saved somewhere too. I don't know if I still have it saved but I might post it if I find it. seriously though i'm not writing anything better than this it's been over a year you've all probably played enough mafia to have improved since this game/ don't play anymore Edited by Teal Hunter, Nov 13 2013, 09:16 PM.
|
![]() |
|
| 1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous) | |
| « Previous Topic · The Graveyard · Next Topic » |









7:51 PM Jul 10