CL Home Link
Latest.
Latest Anime
Full Metal Panic - The Second Raid: Episode 01
Latest Manga
Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles: Volume 24
Latest Soundtrack
Mahoromatic: Updated 5/5/08
Anime/Manga of the Week Winner
Tsubasa: Reservoir Chronicles
Type: Manga
Link to Series
Vote For Next Week
Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
CL's Reviews
Topic Started: Sep 15 2007, 11:02 PM (144 Views)
Jc
Member Avatar
Administrator

I will post our reviews here!


Review #1 - By Mini Maul of Mokata

Number Of Members
6/10
You have 69 members so far which is good because i know you have just started to advertise your board. You now need to push on from here now and get these members posting while your staff advertise everywhere possible to get some more members in. I wouldnt advice doing a refferal type of contest just yet, being you have just opened, try and get as many people as possible before you start thinking about these competitions.

Number Of Posts
6/10
You have a total of 1,883 posts which is an average of about 27 posts per member which is a nice start. Its good to see that some of your members are sticking around to post a bit. Members like Dan The Man, Kira + Fenrir have the highest post count all over 50 which is a nice start. Now you need to keep hold of these members and get them to about 150 posts to keep up that good average while you get in more members, i dont think you need to get a posting type of competition going at the minute because its just the beginning of the board. Let it settle down a bit before you do anything competition related going.

Quality Of Staff
Admin
8/8
I lot of familier faces from past boards. You have great quality for your admins, All three i know are great admins. Jc might not be the most active admin but he does a lot for the board while you have Top Kirby to advertise and get to know all the members while Bluezone is the more sensible one who posts at the board and keeps everything in check. When this board becomes active, you three will not have a problem i dont think because you will be a good team. I also forgot Kei-chan im very sorry he looks active and looks like they can deal with responsiblity. No problems here.

Mods
0/0
You dont have any mods

Other Staff
4/7
You have three other staff. LaughingMan looks like he is nice and active which is encouraging to see your staff want to be involved in the board. Your other tow though are not as active. one of them have about 40 posts which is a slow start but he has started which is good. But you also have one staff member on 6 posts. Maybe he is on holiday or something but he continues to post inactivly then you will have to consider his place there at CL. But overall, its not a bad start for all your staff.

Apearance & Layout
Appearance
14/15
The appearance of you board is great. You have a nice dark skin which isnt too dark, you have great buttons for the board which fit the skin perfectly but the only thing that i dont like is the banner. i dont mind it, it looks fine, but i think it is a bit random, but it looks ok. there isnt much to say for this really. Being there is nothing to say that is wrong. Nice job.

Layout
8/10
Your layout is prfect for a general discussion board. You have the welcome section at the top to draw new posts and members in. You dont have loads of sections so it is easy to look around. The only thing i have noticed was that you might want to split the graphics section up a bit, just so you get peoples signatures in one bit and people who are submitting other things such as forum graphics and that in another area, just so its easier to find what you want. Apart from that, its a reallly nice layout.

Activity
7/10
The activity i cant really mark because being its the start of the new board. It will be active because everyone is coming and i dont know if they are staying or not. Thats what you have to do though, you want to maintain this level of activity, i can see that lots of talking is happening in the cbox. Later on, you might want to get rid of it. or get rid of it now, and then bring it back when your acivity drops down a little bit. Just make a general chat topic for the minute to gain posts rather then them going into that cbox. This will increase activity that little bit more. Get as much acivity as you can because at most forums, it wont last. But at the minute, looks fine.

Overall
53/70
75% or 2 Stars

You have had a really good start.
When you can next get a review here. I think you should get another one to see if you are getting better and to see if your acivity or staff members has got better. I couldnt really review most of the board being it is quite new and things like activity are going to be high for obvious reasons.
But its a nice board and was a pleasure to review.

Thanks for using Mokatas reviewing service

Mini Maul
Mokata Staff
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
SunnyxLove
Member Avatar
Spring of Drowned Girl
That's an 'Okay' review!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tailz
Member Avatar
Why can't you just love me back?
It was old,weve grown alot more now :D Still it was a good review! Lets get 100% next time ^^
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · Association Headlines · Next Topic »
Add Reply

Button Advertisement.
SOTW Winner
Signature of the Week #1 (Theme: Freestyle)
Winner: Kei
Enter Signature of the Week #2 (Theme: Freestyle)
© 2007 - 2008 AMG Paradise - Community Lounge. No copyright Infringements Intended. View Shoutbox | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy