Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Add Reply
some lots of silly questions here
Topic Started: May 30 2013, 04:07 AM (80 Views)
DawnSchwarz
Member Avatar

Not sure if this is the right place to post this, hope it is.
As the title says... I have lots of rulings questions, hope somebody helps me here XP

1. What happens with Astinos, White Knight Spirit's ability if you have less than 4 cards left in your deck (or any similar card that checks the top X cards of the deck)?

2. Can Aldora, White Knight Spirit attack the turn you summon Perfect Galaxy, Spirit of Immortality and use his Shield Force ability?

3. If you don't have any Angel Command in your grave, can you still send to the graveyard one of your opponent's shields with Codenight Black of Lionel's ability?

4. Can you choose Perfect Madonna, Light Weapon for self-removal effects like Transmogrify, Deadly Love, Eureka Program, etc, keep her in the battle zone due to her ability and still complete said spell's other abilities (IE. destroy an opponent's creature in Deadly Love's case, etc)?

That's it for now,
thanks~
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
subzero
Member Avatar

1. You always do as much as possible. You reveal the remaining cards in your deck. Think of it as Kitarou, the Cursed Corpse's ability, if your opponent has 1 card in hand, they are forced to show you that very card. So yes, Astinos can still be used.

2. Yes. Let's take an example. If you have a shield fortified with Saint Castle and a Lord Reis in the battlezone. Whatever creature you summon allows you to draw. Therefore, Perfect should be gaining the blocker with it's ability just like that. Therefore, Aldora should be able to attack. [This is my opinion]

3. Yes. Putting a Command from grave to shield is the second part of the text. It, in no way is a condition for the shield burn to work.

4. Yes. You did destroy Madonna with Eureka/Zabi Mira. Madonna just stayed there with it's effect. Same applies for Perfect Galaxy, Mighty Shouter, Iron-Arm Tribe, etc. The rest of the effect will still happen.

Hope that helped. :D
Edited by subzero, May 30 2013, 12:15 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
DawnSchwarz
Member Avatar

great, thanks Subzero :D

another bunch of questions lol

1. Again with Lionel... let's say my opponent doesn't have any shield left, I summon Lionel, can I add to my shields a Command from my graveyard?

2. If I use Romanoff the First, Lord of the Demonic Eye to cast a Magic Strike Spell from my graveyard. Can I use that Magic Strike's Knight Magic ability?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
subzero
Member Avatar

1. Yes.The former part of the effect of Lionel Black is not a requirement for the second part. Why would you think it is necessary. If it does not make it compulsory, you always do as much as possible.

2. Romanoff just let you cast a spell! Is Romanoff the 1st a Knight? YES! When a spell is cast, are all it's effects followed? YES! Is Knight Magic a part of the effect of the spell? YES! Can you use Knight Magic? Heck YES!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · Rules and Rulings · Next Topic »
Add Reply